Do surgical textbooks have a future? Like traditional
encyclopaedias, they now face competition from
multimedia packages containing sound and video
clips in addition to text and still pictures. Unlike
a book, the reader does not have to switch constantly between text and pictures on CD ROM, you listen
to the description while you look at pictures
or watch a video. CDs can also contain many
more colour pictures than it is economically reasonable
to print in a book.
OTOROM
is an interactive otological surgery package. There are some text based parts explaining the aetiology,
presentation, and natural course of diseases.
However, the largest part of the package describes
the surgical management of various otological problemsùillustrated by a series of excellent microscopic operative photographs, which can be enlarged to fill the viewing screen,
and several video clips. Some are presented
as cases with history, clinical findings, investigations,
medical management, and results of treatment
in addition to step by step surgical management. Often the reader has options in management, such as complications encountered or prostheses used. Moving around is
intuitive and easy?the instructions would fit
on a postcardùand the only necessary computing
skill is the use of a mouse.
This
is an attractive and professional package, as you would expect from its origins. Some of the views expressed
will not meet with universal approval, again
as expected, but they are based on the vast
clinical experience of the Causse Clinic. My one major criticism is that the alternative of fitting
a hearing aid rather than surgery for otosclerosis
is not even mentioned.
All
otological trainees will learn a great deal from this
CD, and it would be excellent preparation for
the final fellowship examination. Most otolaryngologists,
even experienced otologists, will also learn
much from the surgical sections. There were certainly
several operative situations that I have not encountered.
My
first impression of this CD, at a Royal Society of Medicine meeting, was that it looked very pretty but there
seemed to be a lot of time spent waiting for
the next bit to load, though the salesman said
it would run much faster on a powerful computer. Having now run it on a 166 MHz computer with an
eight speed CD ROM drive, I must say the salesman
was right. Changing between topics is quickùas
fast as turning the page in a book, and certainly
much faster than looking up an index and then finding
the appropriate page. This is an impressive package that is much more enjoyable and, with the combination
of pictures and commentary, much easier to
use than a surgical textbook. It takes up much
less room in my crowded study too.
Rating:
***
Iain R C Swan, senior lecturer, Department of Otolaryngology,
Royal Infirmary, Glasgow